Exhuminator wrote:ElkinFencer10 wrote:I don't think we really gain anything from waxing dogmatic about it.
On the other hand, the looser the restrictions and themes become, the less purposeful the event is.
By using the term "spin-offs" though, noise was deliberately opening up wider parameters for people to choose a game. If he wanted to more narrowly define player choices, wording could have been selected that accomplished that, instead.
The definition of FF "spin-off" is debatable, too. For example, your list didn't include Ehrgeriz, but the
Final Fantasy wiki does list it as something related to the series in the same way that Kingdom Hearts is (which was on your list).
I suppose the question is what makes something count as a "spin-off"? For example, that wiki mentions that Super Mario RPG has elements of FF in it:
Given that there was cross-development of FF and some of these other titles, I can see an argument that lots of non-FF games were ultimately "spun off" of the mainline FF series. I mean, the basic definition Google gives me of "spin off" is "a byproduct or incidental result of a larger project." That opens the door pretty wide for a large number of games.