s1rweeze wrote:Monday, December 2, 2013 - Secret of Evermore
Already have negative karma on reddit for this one
Eh, don't worry. You should hear about some of the crap a few of us here have put up with over our articles.
Anyway, as for the game, I agree with you on some important points, such as the shoddy hit detection, though I also would like to point out that the game feels entirely aimless overall for large portions of it, and even when you do receive direction as to what to do next, you rarely actually receive directions on where to go to accomplish this task.
My biggest disagreement with you is over the music, but I'm actually a fan of the ambient soundtrack, so I suppose it is just a difference of taste. I never cared for some of the sound effects, though I think the squish effect works well with the bloody explosion that occurs with it. I always figured the game was trying to be goofy and just not succeeding that well.
Overall, I'm glad you were honest with your criticism, and even if I don't entirely agree, I can definitely see where it comes from. I'm glad you didn't compromise your opinion in the face of potential viewer rage.