I started Secret of Evermore this afternoon.
I played a little of the game before and I have beaten Secret of Mana before, so I knew what I was getting into. Like Mana, I wish the hit detection was a little bit better and the game so far is rather dark, so it is hard to figure out where to go.
But, I enjoyed myself while playing the game. The alchemy system is really unique and I like that items are basically everywhere, so you never feel like you are going to run out. Having only three weapons makes the game a bit more simpler and lets you concentrate on the best weapon at a single time. Also, having a dog as a party member is cute and it also simplifies from Mana as well.
I am not completely wowed yet, but I am enjoying myself, so I am fine with that.