No Spoilers here!
I recently watched an overall fantastic movie which was overburdened by the weight of two worlds.
Captain Marvel gives the audience practically everything we could ask from a Superhero movie. We get to see another Marvel superhero spectacle, but don't assume it's
just another Marvel flick. Captain Marvel takes cues from 1990s action sequels like Terminator 2 and Die Hard With a Vengeance. This means that in addition to superpowered fight scenes, the audience also gets car chases, motorcycle thievery, and witty quips from Samuel L. Jackson. Oh, and 1980s movies fans are going to notice more than one reference to Top Gun. There's a lot to love in this film. Captain Marvel kicks ass, beats the bad guys, saves the universe, and looks good doing it. That really
should be more than enough.
And yet... here we are. It's not enough for Captain Marvel to save just one Universe, because she has to hold up the weight of two universes. On her right hand is the Marvel Cinematic Universe - a behemoth unto itself, and on her left hand is our universe - the real world wherein Captain Marvel has to be everything to everyone.
Marvel Studios is sometimes the victims of their own success. They've knocked it out of the park with so many amazing movies that a merely great movie feels like a relative letdown. If I had never seen Guardians of the Galaxy or The Avengers I would think that Captain Marvel is amazing. At this point, the Marvel Cinematic Universe is so wrapped up in its own lore that it's practically impossible
not to compare one Marvel movie to another. Fans will spend so much time speculating exactly how Nick Fury loses his eye, that no answer can sufficiently fulfill the hype. Fans will find it difficult to enjoy the movie Captain Marvel on its own terms without speculating how the character Captain Marvel will affect the rest of the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
That's a pity because Captain Marvel really would be a tremendous stand-alone film, but standing alone is not a choice when there's crossover money to be made here in the real world. The investors must be appeased, and that means that Captain Marvel
absolutely must team up with the Avengers in the next film. The fans know this too. Satisfying the investors and the fans isn't the only a balancing act here. Brie Larson and Marvel Studios have decided to make a superhero film for feminists (not always an easy group to please) while simultaneously taking care not to alienate their core target demographic. Whether or not Marvel Studios succeeded in pulling off that balancing act is not for me to say. I can only acknowledge that it's a balancing act that most filmmakers wouldn't even begin to attempt. Captain Marvel is being pulled in multiple different directions by the competing interest of investors, fans, film makers, feminists, and core demographics. Any film can only stretch so far.
So what do we have? Captain Marvel is a strong movie all by itself, but it's not stronger than the Marvel Cinematic Universe in which it resides. It's not stronger than the desires of the investors to have another blockbuster summer. It's not stronger than the cultural divide between the feminists and the reactionaries. I wish this film existed in a vacuum without being weighed down by two worlds. Instead Captain Marvel has to work twice as hard as the male superhero movies to achieve as much. What do you call a woman who works twice as hard? I guess you call her... a Marvel.