Of all the posts written past miked's initial one, I agree with Gunstar Green's the most. So I'll respond to it.
Gunstar Green wrote:The entire "front page & forums" model of content creation is largely gone by the wayside and is unattractive to many web users today.
This is 100% on point accurate. People don't seek information like that anymore. I'm not even into social media, and I don't seek information like that anymore.
Gunstar Green wrote:It's one of those things where we've gotten to the point where there's not much left to say.
Exactly. For all the mainstream retro gaming stuff, there's so much information out there concerning it, what's the point of rehashing over and over just to make redundant information available? (Trying to keep up the price indexes is a fool's errand too.) And even for your more esoteric retro gaming needs, sites like HG101, Lost Levels, Tokugawa Corp., and many others have that covered.
Gunstar Green wrote:There are still of course many esoteric games and consoles out there that there isn't much information about but it's largely because most people wouldn't care to discuss them anyway.
I can attest to this truth after attempting to stimulate interest in discussion on such things myself in the forum. So again, making front page articles about retro esoteric gaming is going to be a waste of time (unfortunately).
Gunstar Green wrote:Eventually that community runs out of things to say and conversation goes off in other directions because people still like conversing with their community even though they've got nothing left to say that's technically "on topic."
And that's about where Racketboy is now. The life blood of the site is the forum. And the forum has watered down to a key say 50 or so members that remain active. However, there is an advantage to that. With so few truly active members, we have more of a community going on. A lot of us know a lot about the other members, and you feel like you're talking to an actual person and not just a random anonymous retro game enthusiast. At the same time, familiarity does breed contempt... and I think we've seen some of that in the political thread lately.
Gunstar Green wrote:So it's easy to say, "Let's go back to the old days when all we did was talk about games," but I understand it's a harder thing to actually do especially without a steady stream of new users with fresh perspectives.
So I'm going to
speak selfishly here for a minute.
I know my registration says I joined in 2013, but in reality I've been keeping track of Racketboy for far longer than that. Around 2006 or so is when I started checking up on the place. The thing is,
I have never cared about the articles, but rather the forum. None of the articles have ever enlightened me personally, as I already knew everything I saw there. But rather, I found the forum discussions about gaming to be a lot more interesting. Because even if I already knew what the people were talking about, I at least got to understand their reasoning for the opinions they held.
So the forum is the important part of this site for me. It's why I come here. I enjoy talking to actual adults about gaming in a mature, informed, and respectful sense. I can't get that in real life, none of the other adults I know IRL (sans one) are into gaming at all. Thus if I want to reminisce about classic vintage gaming with a fellow 30-something year old, Racketboy's forum is ideal. Or if I want an educated opinion on a 1995 JRPG before I take the plunge into it, I can get that here. So it is the body of knowledge and informed community that the retro gaming forum here represents, that I find the biggest and best thing about Racketboy. Honestly I don't care about articles, despite the fact that yes they are well written, and yes they help pay for the site to stay online. Everytime I see people bemoaning the lack of updated articles, I just shake my head because
I personally couldn't care less about that. We can pay for the forum directly via contributions, I'm good with that model.
I understand a lot of people think the articles bring new people to the forum, to maintain its fresh influx of new members. However I think that well written forum threads, with deep discussion on their core topics, do just as well via search engines. That's how I found Racketboy way back in the day, due to Google directing me to an archived forum discussion here. So let's keep that forum going! Let's focus on new and old gaming discussion, more heavily than political poop slinging at least. If every active member here would create a new gaming discussion thread even just once a month, I think that would go a long way to maintaining momentum. ALSO lurkers stop just leeching entertainment out of other people's posts and actually do some posting yourself. Who knows, you might shake things up in a way that's good for everybody.